Title:Halloween Surprise Author: Jules - mailto:slash_me_baby@yahoo.com Genre:Slash Pairing:Nick Carter/Justin Timberlake
		Rating:		NC-17
		Disclaimer: This is not real, it never happened. Halloween Surprise by Jules Nick looked around and couldn't believe that he was actually doing this. Even though he knew no one would recognize him, could recognize him, a tremor of fear shot through his entire body. It was the one day of the year that he could go somewhere public in a costume and not look suspicious. The group had the night off and Nick decided that he was going to do what HE wanted, and that was to go to a bar. A gay bar. He'd been to a few in the past and everyone suspected that it was just because he was open minded, he was comfortable enough in his own heterosexuality that he could go to a gay bar and not feel threatened. He had always laughed inwardly, thinking if they only knew. He didn't go for that reason, he went because he was gay. Not bi, not bi-curious, but gay. None of the guys in the group knew, it wasn't something he was ready to reveal to anyone yet. He'd do it in his own time in his own way, but for now he just wanted to revel in the one secret he had from the world. The on e part of his life that no one could touch or pick apart. So he went out and found a costume and got ready to go to the Halloween Bash down at Rainbow, a highly respected Gay bar in downtown Orlando. Walking into the club Nick smiled to himself. No one would ever suspect that he was Nick Carter in this outfit. He had chosen a tight red lycra outfit and a red mask, dressed up as a Devil. The mask covered the better part of his face, leaving only his eyes and mouth exposed. He had dyed his hair jet black to compliment the red costume which clearly displayed his finely toned muscles. Nick looked good and felt even better. The entire way in the limo to the club he had been experiencing a weird feeling that tonight was going to be special, that something was going to happen. He wasn't sure what that was but was open for possibilities. He hoped to meet a nice guy at the party and maybe get to know him better. Someone who will would like him before he found out who he was and be able to understand his need for privacy and secrecy. Taking in the scenery before him, a song came on that Nick loved so he decided to go to the dance floor. He found an empty spot on the floor and began to m ove his body to the music, watching the people around him move in a similar fashion. He was there for maybe twenty minutes before he saw him. Nick's pulse began to race and his breathing quickened. He had never seen anyone as sexy or beautiful in his life. This guy was dressed as an angel of some sorts and Nick chuckled at the irony of it. The guy was wearing a pair of white spandex shorts, no shirt and a pair of angel's wings harnessed to his back. His body was covered from head to toe in glitter and his face was covered in a mask similar to Nick's red one, but in white. His hair was cut in a buzz cut, and Nick could see a beautiful cross tattoo on the man's shoulder. Nick felt his groin tighten and he knew that this was the one. This was the guy he'd been hoping to find. Justin was so lost in the music that he had pushed everyone and everything around him out of his mind. He had heard from a friend that the Halloween Bash at Rainbow's was to die for and that everyone who was anyone would be there. Justin didn't for sure know who everyone was, but if they were gonna be there so was he. He'd told the guys that he had promised to help a friend with their demo tape that night and so he couldn't go to the Halloween party that they were throwing. This was something that he needed to do alone. He wanted to go to a gay bar and see what the lifestyle was like, what it would be like to be free to be openly gay, not worried about what people would say or how they'd react. He was tired of holding it in, lying to everyone about his relationship with Britney. Yeah he loved her, but he wasn't in love with her. He could never be in love with her because she wasn't what he wanted. She could never be what he wanted, she was a woman. So he hopped a cab and found his way down to the club, amazed at the fact that he walked into the club and no one even flinched. There were no screaming girls, no hoards of fans and no flashing cameras. It was wall to wall people just dancing and laughing, having a good time. As the song changed, Justin opened his eyes for a brief moment, taking in the surroundings. There were more people there than when he had started to dance, and looked around to see if he could see anyone he wanted to dance with. He shifted the wings on his shoulders and cursed them. Why in the hell had he decided to wear these things anyways? They were constantly throwing him off balance and hitting other people trying to dance. Looking in the mirror his eyes met someone's across the floor. Someone was staring at him and he blushed, biting his lip and looking down. After a few seconds Justin looked up and saw that the person was still there, dancing and watching him with keen interest. He was dressed all in red, a devil's costume Justin figured. He laughed and turned to face the man, beckoning him over with his smile.

		Nick saw the angel smile at him and he thought this was his chance. Now or never so Nick slowly made his way over to where he was dancing and paused. He'd never done this before and wasn't sure exactly what to do or what to say. "Hey." He managed, licking his lips and trying not to stare at the strangers' flat stomach and muscled chest. "Hey yourself. Wanna dance?" The angel asked shyly, staring Nick in the eyes. Nick couldn't speak, he just nodded moving his body to the music, careful not to touch the other man. Justin had to fight not to moan as he looked into the stranger's eyes. He had the bluest eyes Justin had ever seen before and he found himself getting lost in them. And then when he started to dance, it was all Justin could do to not grab ahold of him and press himself against him. As they started to move Justin looked up at the stranger and smiled, "Name's Justin." He saw the other man smile back and snake his arm around Justin's waist bringing him closer, "Nickolas". He breathed, grinding closer to Justin and falling into a seductive rhythm. Justin immediately froze up and paused, unsure of what to say. "Ummm..." 'Yeah Justin?" The other man asked, his eyes soft and his voice low. "This.. I mean. I've never... Well you see... This is my first time at this type of place. I've never.. Uhhh well...." Justin stammered, embarrassed by his nervousness. He felt Nickolas chuckle and wrap his arms around him tighter, pulling Justin's face so that they were standing forehead to forehead. "You wanna know the truth Justin?" Nick waited for Justin to nod and he continued. "Mine too. I've never been to a place like this before either, so I understand." Nick looked deep into Justin's eyes and saw the relief clearly displayed. They continued to dance like that, bodies grinding against one another, foreheads touching lightly, masks hiding their true identities. Nick couldn't hold on any longer. He could feel Justin's breath on his mouth and he wanted to feel his lips there. Wanted to kiss him, tasting the sweetness he knew he'd find behind those lips. "Justin?" Nick asked, moaning as Justin's hands found their way down to Nick's ass, pulling them closer and causing their hard erections to rub one another. "Yeah." "Kiss me." Nick saw Justin's mouth turn into a smile before he leaned in and captured Nick's mouth in a soft, tentative kiss. They continued to kiss softly, until finally Nick needed more. He opened his mouth slightly so that he could flick his tongue against Justin's lips asking for entrance. Justin moaned at the sensation giving Nick the opportunity to taste what he had been thinking about all night. "God you taste so good." Nick moaned as he pulled away from Justin. Not wanting the kiss to be over so soon, Justin leaned in and took Nick's lower lip in his teeth, sucking on it. Soon the music and other people at the bar were forgotten as Nick and Justin got lost in the sensations of each other. They kissed and touched one another while dancing, acquainting themselves with each others' bodies. In the short time they knew one another, Nick found that Justin's neck was very sensitive and he liked it when Nick licked and sucked at his collar bone. He'd let out little mewling sounds while his fingers would tangle themselves in Nick's short black spikes. Justin learned how sensitive Nickolas' backside was, and how much he loved it when Justin would touch and squeeze it. Also that Nickolas loved to kiss. And god could he kiss well. It blew Justin's mind away the things that this man could make him feel in the short time that he knew him. Before both men knew it, it was last call at the bar and almost time to go home. Neither wanted the night to end, but both had reservations in extending it. Finally Nick realized that he wasn't going to let this opportunity go to waste. For once he was going to be a normal 21 year old guy and do what he wanted to do. "Justin...come home with me?" It was a question more than a statement, and his voice was thick with lust and nervousness. Justin just paused, as if he was thinking this over and Nick's heart was beating rapidly. "Okay." He finally said, putting his hand in Nick's and leaning up to kiss him passionately on the mouth, letting his tongue ravage Nick's. They both groaned loudly, gasping for breath as they pulled away. Making their way to the door Nick winked at Justin and led him to his limo that was waiting for him. "This your ride?" Justin asked surprised. "Ummm. Yeah. Is this okay?" Nick was nervous. They'd spent all night talking and making out, but he still hadn't told Justin who he was. He wasn't sure how the other man would take it and hoped he wasn't too mad. "No it's fine. Just surprised that you have a limo." Justin said, climbing into the car first. He thought it was weird that this random guy at the bar had a limo waiting, but then figured that he just probably had a lot of money. JC had told Justin that a lot of posh people frequented Rainbow so it wasn't all that odd.

		Sitting back into the seat, Justin turned his head to see Nick smiling at him, a gleam in his eyes. "What?" Justin asked. "Why are you all the way over there?" Nick asked back, motioning for Justin to come closer. Justin smiled shyly and slid over so that he was right next to Nick. Nick took ahold of Justin's hand and pulled him so that he could straddle him, both men feeling the other's erections through their thin costume material. "God you're so beautiful Justin." Nick moaned as he ran his fingers up Justin's chest, stopping to trace his nipples and watch the look of ecstasy cross his face. Justin couldn't believe how good Nickolas' hands felt on his skin. He wanted to feel Nickolas everywhere and began to rock their hips together, creating a sweet friction. He leaned down and kissed Nickolas, making love to his mouth with his tongue. They continued like this until Justin felt Nick's hands at his stomach, playing with the rim of his shorts. His hands traveled lower and began to rub Justin through his shorts, bringing his already hard cock further to life. "Oh god... That feels so good Nickolas... Touch me more..." Justin moaned, throwing his head back and leaning into Nick's touch. He wanted more, needed more. Just as he felt Nick's fingers slide into his shorts the intercom buzzed and broke through the thick air. "Mr Carter. There seems to be a slight delay thanks to a traffic accident. It will take longer to reach your home than planned." Both men stopped instantly, faces a mask of fear and confusion. "Thank you James. That will be fine." Nick said, his voice shaking. Oh god. He hoped that Justin wouldn't put two and two together and realize that he'd said his name was Nickolas and the driver just said his last name was Carter. Judging by the look on Justin's face his cover was blown. Carter? Carter? Justin's mind was whirling. It couldn't be. How could it be? What would Nick Carter be doing at a gay bar? Picking up MEN? Nick wasn't "gay". But then neither was he technically. Well not to the public anyways. So if he was gay, and he was at that bar, it was all together possible that Nick fucking Carter could be gay and at that bar too. Suddenly Justin was caught in between horrified and so turned on it was painful. He looked Nickolas in the eyes and saw the familiarity in the depth of them. Justin sat back and took a good look at the other man and wondered how he hadn't seen it before. He reached up slowly, as to not alarm Nick and fingered the mask covering half his face. "Can I take this off?" Justin was amazed at how steady his voice was. It was soft and curious, so not what he was feeling inside. Nick couldn't do anything but nod. He knew this was going to happen at some point of the night so he might as well just get it over with. His face turned a deep crimson and he shut his eyes as he felt Justin pull the mask away. Nick's eyes opened at the gasp he heard come from Justin's mouth. Biting his lip he looked the other man in the eye and furrowed his brows in nervousness. "Ummm. Hey." Nick whispered. He had no idea what to do or say at this moment. Justin was in complete shock. It was Nick Carter. This amazing man that he had this unspeakable connection to was Nick Carter. He wasn't sure if he was relieved or scared at this revelation. "Justin, please say something." He heard Nick say softly and his heart throbbed. Nick was just as scared as he was and that comforted him. "Hey." Justin whispered leaning forward and softly kissing Nick's lips before pulling back and climbing off of him. "I know I should have said something sooner... But you have to understand why I didn't. You don't realize the frenzy that will follow if this gets out.." Nick started to say, worried about what was going to happen next. Before he could finish he watched in shock as Justin removed his mask and looked at him, sheepish grin on his face. "I think I know what you're trying to say Carter." Nick's jaw dropped and his stomach lurched. Justin Timberlake? There was no way that this guy was Justin freakin Timberlake. "What the fuck? How? Why? When? What?" Nick stuttered, his mind racing a mile a minute. "Is this a joke?" Justin shook his head and placed it in his hands. "It's not a joke Nick. I can't fucking believe this." He chuckled softly and looked at Nick who's face was still that of shock. "You asked why, where, when and how? Ask yourself the same questions and I think you'll find the answers." As both men thought about their own situations and the other's everything became clear. "I didn't want anyone to know... Still too new .....too fresh." Justin said. "I know what you mean. I never knew that you.." His voice was soft and sympathetic. "No one does. Well JC does sort of, but not really. You?" "No one knows." Nick and Justin stared at one another for a few minutes before spontaneously breaking out into laughter. "How funny is this Carter?" Justin asked, the nervousness dissipating and a sense of calm taking over.

		"Unbelievable." Nick replied, smiling. "Now.. Ummmmm now what?" Justin's face went a shade of red and he looked down at the carpet, unsure if he should ask the question on his mind. "Did... Did you mean what you said?' "What did I say?" Nick asked, not sure of what Justin meant exactly. "Well.. When you said I was beautiful." Justin couldn't look Nick in the eyes. It was Nick's turn to blush now and he suddenly became very interested in the upholstery of the limo. "Yeah.. I did Justin. You are so beautiful." When he looked up he saw that same look of desire and lust in the younger man's eyes and he felt himself harden at sight. "Good. Because I think you're beautiful Nick. You've made me feel something so different but amazing tonight. And I don't want who we are to fuck that up. That's why I wanted the mask tonight. I'm so sick of not being able to do what I want because of who I am." Justin looked at Nick and knew that he understood more than anyone else would be able to. Nick bit his lip in nervousness and Justin felt his stomach flip, his cock harden. "I want you so much right now Nick. Please tell me that this doesn't change anything." Justin waited for Nick's response, looking up when he felt the older man move on the seat beside him. Just as he was about to turn to face him, he felt Nick at his side, his hands trailing up Justin's arms and back. "Oh god Justin.... I want you too." Nick breathed turning Justin's head so their mouths could meet in a feverish kiss. They fell back onto the limo seats, arms wrapped tightly around one another, mouths locked at the tongue. Not wanting their first time together to be in the back of a limo, Nick and Justin restrained themselves for the remainder of the ride to Nick's house. Only going as far as kissing and touching. The second that they reached Nick's house, they made their way up to his bedroom stopping only to turn on some music and pull down the sheets of the bed. Nick took his time undressing the minimal clothing Justin was wearing, amazed at how beautiful the younger man's body was. Nick wanted to lick and kiss every inch of Justin and jumped as he felt him tug at his costume. "I want you out of these clothes Carter. I want to see just how beautiful you are under that suit." Nick groaned and wrestled with the lycra costume he was wearing. When he finally freed himself from the clothing they stood there looking at one another, unable to speak from awe. Nick made the first move, stepping closer to Justin and trailing his fingers down his chest, stopping at his nipples. Justin gasped at the feel of Nick's rough thumbs rolling over his hardened buds, wanting to feel his hands everywhere else. "Oh ... Nick.. Please don't tease me like this.. I want to feel your mouth..." Justin reached up and grabbed Nick's face, pulling him close for a kiss. As they did this, Nick's hands moved south to grasp Justin's erection firmly, stroking and massaging it. He felt Justin moan into his mouth and chuckled, loving the reaction he was getting from this. "Nick... What do you want to do? How far do you want to take this?" Justin asked, his head swimming with pleasure. Nick was about to speak when he felt Justin's hand grasp him, inflicting the same torture that he himself was giving Justin. "Oh fuck baby...... I want it all. I want you to fuck me... Please fuck me." "OH GOD!" Justin screamed. Hearing Nick's plea shocked Justin beyond belief. In fact, he was so shocked and turned on that he came instantly, covering Nick's hand with his sticky cum. They both froze instantly, their faces mirroring the shock that they were feeling from Justin's orgasm. Justin's face turned a very scarlet red, embarrassed for cumming so soon, Nick's the same shade but more in arousal than anything. He couldn't believe that he had just made Justin cum like that. Just his hand and his voice was enough to bring this man to orgasm, Nick felt fucking amazing right now. "I'm so sorry.... I can't believe I just fucking came...." Justin stuttered, trying to pull out of Nick's grasp. Nick took a firm hold of Justin, pulling him near. "Oh my god Justin. That was the sexiest thing I've ever seen. Watching you cum like that, knowing it was for me... Oh god baby..." He leaned down and took Justin's mouth with his, licking his way down Justin's neck. "I'll just have to get you ready again so you can fuck me with that beautiful cock of yours. You never did answer me though Just... Do you want to fuck me?" Nick looked up from Justin's chest where he was licking off drops of the younger man's cum, his eyes a dark shade of blue. Hearing Nick's voice so low and raspy was enough to get Justin hard again. He could feel his erection returning and running his fingers in Nick's hair he smiled. "Oh fuck Nick. I want to fuck you so bad. I want to feel how hot and tight you are. How good you're gonna feel while I'm fucking you." "Good." Was all Nick said as he got down on his knees and took Justin's semi-hard cock in his mouth, licking and sucking the tip before engulfing it entirely. The room began to spin for Justin, his eyes shut tight not wanting to forget one moment of what was happening. Nick sucked Justin until he felt that he was ready. He only wanted Justin hard, not ready to cum just yet. Justin groaned as he felt Nick's mouth leave him. He opened his eyes and saw Nick smirking at him, leading him to the bed. "How do you want to do this lover? On my knees or my back?" Justin couldn't believe this was actually happening, that he was about to fuck a man. And not just any man,

		Nick Carter. "On your back, I want to be able to watch your face as we do this. I want to remember everything about this night." Justin breathed, kissing Nick softly and pushing him onto the bed. When they were both settled comfortably, Justin took the lube that Nick offered him and prepared them both. He groaned as he placed himself at Nick's entrance and began his decent into Nick's warm body. Where it was pure pleasure for Justin, Nick was in more pain than he had ever been in his life. He'd never felt like this before and although he knew he needed to feel the pain before the pleasure, it sucked. A few tears dropped from his eyes and Justin wiped them away, whispering words of love and comfort to Nick. Once the pain ended and Nick adjusted to Justin's intrusion of his body, he began to push back on him. Justin sunk in further and moaned loudly, hoping that he 'd be able to hold on long enough to make this good for Nick too. He'd never felt anything as good as what he was feeling now, and Justin knew at that moment that this was who he was, where he was supposed to be. "Justin... Move... Please..." Nick pleaded, needing relief. With a sigh, Justin began, thrusting in and out of Nick at a slow, measured pace. His eyes were focused on Nick's the entire time, registering the pain and pleasure that his lover was getting from their union. Nick wasn't entirely sure that he was enjoying being bottom in this position until Justin thrust in and hit his prostate, causing him to tremble violently. "Oh god.. Right there.. Fucking hit right there Justin" Nick screamed as Justin repeatedly slammed into Nick, hitting his prostate every time. Reaching up to stroke his cock, he kept pace with Justin's thrusts. Justin leaned down to kiss Nick, covering Nick's hand with his own. As soon as Nick felt Justin's hand on his cock, his tongue in his mouth he couldn't hold on any longer and came, moaning Justin's name into his mouth loudly. He clenched around Justin who was still thrusting wildly, and he felt the younger man tense considerably and cum hard, his entire body shaking above Nick. They both remained in this position for quite some time, Justin resting on Nick's chest, his head tucked under his chin, with Nick's legs still around his waist, their fingers tangled in one another. Nick felt Justin's breathing slow and a sigh escape from his mouth. "You okay Justin?" He asked softly, stroking his lover's sweat covered back lovingly. "I've never been better Nick." Justin replied leaning up and looking Nick in the eye. He wasn't sure what he was looking for, but he wanted to see what was in Nick's face. In his soul. As much as he wanted whatever he found tonight to be a one time thing, he didn't. He hadn't been looking for anything serious when he went to that bar tonight, but it seemed as though he found something he hadn't even known he was looking for. A relationship would definitely be difficult for him, almost impossible, but he knew that Nick understood that and was in the same position. For that reason, whatever THIS was, might just be able to work. He stared into Nick's eyes and was surprised at what he saw there. "Amazing isn't it?" Nick asked, cupping Justin's face and pulling him down for a kiss. "What?" "This. That we both went to Rainbows for one thing, and came out with something entirely different. Better... Amazing." Nick smiled at Justin and felt butterflies in his stomach. He had never realized before tonight, just how beautiful Justin was. "What is this exactly Nick?" "Whatever we want it to be Justin. We both know that it's gonna be hard, nearly impossible, but I don't care. I don't want this to be a one time thing." "Neither do I Nick. I want more. More with you." Justin replied, kissing Nick before pulling out of Nick completely and rolling so that he was snuggled in beside him, their arms and legs wrapped around one another. "Happy Halloween Nick." He mumbled as sleep began to overtake him. Grinning as he vaguely heard Nick reply back, "Happy Halloween Justin."